Delicious butterscotch pie! Can't wait to go back for the Buckeye pie. My family lives one hour North and I live one hour South. A great place to meet in the middle. Food and service is AWESOME!!! The old time candy was nostalgic. We were like kids in a candy store. ;) There are just a lot of goodies everywhere you look. You gotta go!

This restaurant was amazing! I truly loved the restaurant ambience and the friendliness of the staff. My grandbaby loved the Mashed Potatoes and green beans! She ate all her delicious sweet applesauce! The Liver and Onions that I ordered was amazing! Definitely recommend and definitely going back again when traveling in the area.

What a gem! My husband and I were driving from Columbus to New Hampshire and stopped here for some lunch. We are so happy we did. This is home cooking and hospitality at its best. One of the best things about it is that it's a pretty old restaurant and it seems to be going strong. Stop here if you're ever traveling through Utica, Ohio!

Ask for Theresa, she is a great server. Food is fantastic, service is extrordinary, Management is superior. Comfortable, friendly patrons, and a pleasant experience all around. Highly recommended.

We arrived late not knowing they closed at 7pm The waitress was so nice she kept Saying don't you rush we have an hour of clean up take your time. She was the sweetest. She said she enjoy the job and people and only works two days a week now being older she said. Wow I would just come back when she is there. She just made our night. But let's get to the food. It was excellent. I had liver and onions lots of them. My husband had beef tips that melt in your mouth. Of course we got pie to go was so full. We will be back for sure.

The food is really good, but sometimes over salted. The service is kinda slow but really good at the same time. The ambiance of the place is really old feeling

Service was great and the pie selection was off the charts. Roast beef with dressing & fried okra were delicious. Green beans, mac&cheese and fried walleye big disappointment. Would we come back, yes.

Do you like pie? This is the place for the best pies in the state of Ohio. The down home menu is also full of delectable favorites. The perfect spot to eat after visiting Velvet Ice Cream nearby.

I'd never even been to Utica but after going to check out the lack of progress on his hot rod getting painted I said, let's go to wherever makes you happy so Watt's was where he chose. It's an old house so setup of the place is a little wonky but it's very inviting. Almost feels like you've stepped in to the past. The bakery items are the 1st thing that catches your eye; fresh baked loaves of bread, cakes, muffins and my favorite, pies bit fruit and cream based. Off to our table which was by the fireplace. Cozy. Greeted almost immediately and asked us all sorts of questions like we were long lost cousins. Check out the menu and brother orders what is a Thanksgiving dinner; Turkey, mashed potato, dressing and a side salad. I order the chicken fried steak, bean soup along with mac&cheese. Everything arrived quickly, it was still steaming hot no less. The server stated that everything is made there from scratch. Server brought us a couple rolls and they were delicious and brought back memories of holiday dinners at my grandparents. Actually, our meals were just so mouthwatering and the flavors backed up our anticipation. Walking out, I see they have bags of the rolls so I grab some of them and a loaf of bread that is baked by local Amish store Hershberger's. My suggestion would be to go to Watts for lunch, then head over to Hershberger's. This would be a spectacular day trip. This part of Ohio is lovely during the Fall. I read in another review that stated, 'the best comfort food ever.' And I 100% agree. #SupportLocal #Mom&Pops

Hubby and I were on a mission to find some peaches! Well, a mission will have to include a new place to eat..Lol.. Sunday afternoon drive in the country and found this little gem in Utica. We first pulled in, nice size parking lot that was completely full..it was 1:30pm. People sitting on benches outside waiting.. Full lot and people waiting and no one complaining about a wait is a great sign. We only waited around 20 minutes to get a table. There's a few different rooms with some nice comfy booths and tables and chairs. Inside gives you an old diner kind of feel. Nice and clean, cozy too. Looking at the menu, they have a lot of food options. We ordered some mozzarella sticks and ice tea to start. Mozzarella sticks came out nice and crispy with a sweet red sauce which we thought was yummy. I ordered the crispy chicken with 2 sides mashed potatoes and Mac and Cheese. Hubby ordered the Smothered Meatloaf with mashed potatoes and Mac and cheese. Food came out nice and hot with nice sized portions. My chicken was nice and crispy and good flavor. Sides were also good. Hubby loved the meatloaf. He ate every last bite of his. Lol..I think he could of used a roll to clean up the rest off his plate. We very much enjoyed our lunch. It reminded us of going to Amish country to eat but, we didn't have to go as far..Lol. We were too full to have dessert but I did get a piece of cherry cheesecake for home. Forget to take a pic of it. Ate it too fast. We can't air to go back and try something different next time. I forgot to add on the way out..there's desserts to buy! Cookies, rolls, pies and lots of pies, fruit pies, cream pies! Forgot to ask if made in house. Looked wonderful!!!